• Home
  • Blog
  • BIO
  • Resume
  • COACHING
  • TEACHING & LEADING
    • A Focus on Meaningful Experience
    • A Focus on Retention
    • TECH INTEGRATION
  • PROFESSIONAL GROWTH
    • CONFERENCE PRESENTATIONS
    • PUBLICATIONS
  • Home
  • Blog
  • BIO
  • Resume
  • COACHING
  • TEACHING & LEADING
    • A Focus on Meaningful Experience
    • A Focus on Retention
    • TECH INTEGRATION
  • PROFESSIONAL GROWTH
    • CONFERENCE PRESENTATIONS
    • PUBLICATIONS

BLOG

What difference can meaningful PE make?

6/28/2026

19 Comments

 
As I've written previously, our department used data to move towards a more meaningful approach to physical education. Throughout this blog, I distinguish between meaningful PE as a broader educational philosophy that places priority on meaningful experiences and Meaningful PE as the pedagogical framework. This distinction matters here because, while our collaborative teaching emphasized student voice and often considered the potential for meaningful experiences, it would be misleading every teacher in our department consistently implemented the Meaningful PE framework or shared the same pedagogical practices - regardless, I am grateful to have worked with a talented group of educators.  

None the less, as my free trial of IBM Statistics Pro comes to an end, I am curious to explore how students experiences have changed or remained the same based on their quantitative responses to the survey questions we administered twice yearly - using a 4 point likert scale (1 - strongly disagree to 4 - strongly agree).

It does not take a statistical analysis program to identify means and compare them, so what I hope to explore is the p-value and 95% confidence interval in Independent Samples T-Test comparing students across different school years as our implementation of more meaningful approaches progressed over time. A p-value tells us how convincing the evidence is that two groups are actually different. A small p-value means the difference is unlikely to be due to chance alone. A large p-value means the difference could easily have occurred by chance, so we can't be confident the groups truly differ.
  • > .10 Little evidence of a difference
  • .05–.10 Some evidence (suggestive)
  • < .05   Good evidence of a difference
  • < .01   Strong evidence of a difference
  • < .001. Very strong evidence of a difference (a 0.01% chance it was random).
A 95% confidence interval is a related metric representing the range of values where we think the "real" difference most likely lies. As a matter of statistical significance, if the interval crosses zero (ex. -0.30 to 0.50) then the findings are statistically insignificant (ouch!), as it would be statistically possible that no difference has occurred. 

2022/23 vs. 2024/25

During the 22/23 school year we spent time building a vision for PE centred on meaningful experiences. Certainly, PE was already meaningful to some, but we used these survey questions to start to identify how our program needed to evolve to be meaningful for all. In 23/24 we began implementing MPE in Grade 8, and began expanding the approach into Grade 7 and 9 the following year (24/25), which involved greater student autonomy, introduction of new activities like skateboarding, kayaking and biking while also orienting our teaching more to what students wanted to learn and get better at.  The first question I was interested was "how has the experience of students in our PE program changed over the past three years?" The table below highlights the difference between survey results in 22/23 vs. 24/25. Statistically significant findings are identified in green, while findings in yellow, despite showing some improvement, were statistically insignificant (again, ouch!) 
Picture
What Stands Out to ME
​

Expected: The first two statistically significant statements related to personally relevant goals and just-right challenges were expected as these were some of the areas we focused on as a department - having students identify challenges, set goals for their perform and orient our teaching towards them. Although I would have expected these to also correlate with feelings of improvement (more on that later).

Unexpected: I was pleasantly surprised to see enjoyment as significant as interestingly we rarely talk about enjoyment or planning for it as a department. This perhaps highlights the way enjoyment can be correlated with other features such as novelty, challenge, growth etc. which I've written about here using the same data set.

Class of 2028: From Grade 7 to Grade 9

While I find the previous data interesting and generally positive - I wonder how much of the change can be associated with a philosophical and pedagogical shift, and how much is it due to the change in students as a new crop of Grade 7s enter each year, and Grade 9s move onto high school. However, there was one group, the graduating class of 2028 that entered Grade 7 in 2022/23 when we were just beginning our data collection, taking stock of how students experience the program but had not yet began to move towards a more meaningful approach to PE in the following year (when they were in Grade 8). Essentially, this group had experienced both "non-MPE" and "MPE" (or at the very least "mPE") throughout their Middle School careers. Again, statistically significant findings are noted in green. 
Picture
What Stands Out to Me
  • ​If someone was to ask "which question would you most like to be significant" I would probably say PE inspiring me to be active outside of school as it links to the continuous aims of PE. To see that represented in the data was particularly meaningful to me, considering this has been a source of intention in our discussion.
  • Even though the p value and confidence intervals are comparing their Grade 7 to Grade 9 year, the incremental growth in some areas that occurs in Grade 8 and continues onto Grade 9, maybe this sheds some light on the pace at which change can move at in terms of the way it is experienced by students. 
  • Although the decline in perceptions of improvement is statistically insignificant, I wonder if the lack of much movement at all speaks to the structure of our curriculum. There are certainly novel experiences at each grade level but they also do basketball, volleyball, badminton etc. every year. And while as the teacher, I am noticed growth, perhaps we need to rethink about how we can help students come to realize that growth as well.

In my own reflection, perhaps the most encouraging finding isn't that Meaningful PE "worked," but that it appeared to make a difference over time. Educational change is rarely immediate. It is often incremental, built lesson by lesson, relationship by relationship, and experience by experience. Across three years, students increasingly reported looking forward to PE, pursuing personally relevant goals, and feeling inspired to be active beyond school. Not every measure changed, and not every change was statistically significant, but I will consider this a "win"! 

If you're looking for some of the teaching examples that these students experienced. I've linked a few here. 
  • Active in My Community
  • Meaningful PE and Do No Harm in Movement Composition
  • Exploring Challenge Through Trail Running


19 Comments
Residential Therapy for Depression link
7/3/2026 12:06:38 am

Residential Therapy for Depression – Intensive residential therapy programs offering continuous support for depression recovery.

Reply
Holistic Depression Treatment Centers link
7/7/2026 01:07:52 am

Holistic Depression Treatment Centers – Centers combining traditional therapies with holistic approaches to support depression recovery.

Reply
24 Hour Detox Centers link
7/14/2026 02:25:43 am

24-hour detox centers offer round-the-clock medical care and monitoring to ensure safety and comfort during the withdrawal process.

Reply
Book Illustration link
7/17/2026 12:23:43 am

Professional book illustration adds visual storytelling and personality to books for children and readers of all ages.

Reply
Best Psychiatrist Phoenix link
7/24/2026 02:52:59 am

Find the best psychiatrist in Phoenix for comprehensive mental health care and personalized treatment. Expert providers offer compassionate support to help you achieve lasting emotional well-being.

Reply
Residential Treatment Centers for Bipolar Disorder link
7/24/2026 11:05:27 pm

Residential Treatment Centers for Bipolar Disorder – Specialized residential care focused on stabilizing and managing bipolar disorder.

Reply
Dual DIagnosis Treatment Centers for Adolescent link
7/25/2026 02:27:06 am

Integrated treatment centers addressing both mental health disorders and substance use in adolescents. Comprehensive care supports lasting recovery and wellness.

Reply
Adolescent Inpatient Services link
7/26/2026 11:14:33 pm

Adolescent Inpatient Services – Intensive inpatient services delivering around-the-clock psychiatric care and therapeutic support for adolescents.

Reply
Postpartum Depression Facility link
7/28/2026 02:28:11 am

Postpartum Depression Facility – Compassionate care for new mothers experiencing postpartum depression with specialized therapeutic support.

Reply
Medication Management Psychiatrist link
7/28/2026 11:28:20 pm

A medication management psychiatrist carefully evaluates, prescribes, and monitors medications to help patients achieve better mental health outcomes.

Reply
Heartwarming and funny dog story link
8/3/2026 03:49:51 am

Heartwarming and Funny Dog Story – A joyful dog story blending humor, friendship, and inspiring messages for children.

Reply
Teen Depression Treatment Center link
8/6/2026 12:01:47 am

A teen depression treatment center provides professional care, counseling, and medication management for adolescents with depression.

Reply
Adolescent Residential Treatment Centers for Mental Health link
8/20/2026 02:23:59 am

Adolescent Residential Treatment Centers for Mental Health: Residential centers offering structured, personalized mental health care for adolescents.

Reply
Residential Facilities for Schizophrenics link
8/27/2026 02:07:30 am

Residential settings providing structured mental health support for people with schizophrenia.

Reply
publishing companies in America link
9/3/2026 04:10:04 am

Publishing Companies in America: Discover U.S.-based publishing companies offering services for authors across different genres.

Reply
barnes and noble self publishing link
9/22/2026 04:37:46 am

Barnes & Noble self-publishing offers authors a platform for preparing and distributing books while maintaining greater involvement in the publishing process.

Reply
LGBTQ Couples Photography Houston link
10/23/2026 03:57:59 am

LGBTQ Couples Photography Houston: Inclusive couples photography in Houston celebrating LGBTQ+ love, connection, and individuality.

Reply
Houston Lifestyle Photographer link
10/24/2026 02:23:09 am

Houston Lifestyle Photographer: Natural lifestyle photography capturing genuine emotions, everyday moments, and personal stories.

Reply
medical memoir link
11/11/2026 12:03:16 am

Explore personal journeys of doctors and healthcare professionals through their medical careers. Discover emotional experiences, memorable patient encounters, professional challenges, and valuable life lessons.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Write something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview.

    Archives

    June 2026
    January 2025
    November 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    November 2023
    October 2023
    May 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    June 2022
    February 2022
    October 2021
    April 2021
    February 2021

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly